Showing posts with label rule 57 ROC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rule 57 ROC. Show all posts

Security Bank vs. Great Wall, et. al., G.R. No. 219345, January 30, 2017 (preliminary attachment)


Security Bank Corporation vs. Great Wall Commercial Press Company, Inc., Alfredo Buriel Atienza, Fredino Cheng Atienza, and Sps. Frederick Cheng Atienza, and Monica Cu Atienza
G.R. No. 219345
Second Division
January 30, 2017
Ponente: Mendoza, J.

Gist:
The 1997 Rules of Court now conspicuously includes the phrase “in the performance thereof” in Section 1(d) of Rule 57. Hence, the fraud committed in the performance of the obligation (dolo incidente) is now included as a ground for the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment, together with the fraud committed in contracting an obligation (dolo causante).

Facts:

In May 2013, Security Bank filed a complaint for Sum of Money (with Application for Issuance of a Writ of Preliminary Attachment) against respondents Great Wall Commercial Press Company, Inc. (Great Wall) and its sureties, Alfrefo Buriel Atienza, Fredino Cheng Atienza and Monica Cu Atienza (respondents), before the RTC. The complaint sought to recover from respondents their unpaid obligations under a credit facility covered by several trust receipts and surety agreements. The total principal amount sought was PHP 10,000,000.00.

After due hearing, the RTC granted the application for a writ of preliminary attachment of Security Bank, which then posted a bond in the amount of PHP 10,000,000.00.

On June 2013, respondents filed their Motion to Lift Writ of Preliminary Attachment Ad Cautelam, claiming that the writ was issued with grave abuse of discretion based on the following grounds: (1) Security Bank’s allegations in its application did not show a prima facie basis therefor; (2) the application and the accompanying affidavits failed to allege at least one circumstance which would show fraudulent intent on their part; and (3) the general imputation of fraud was contradicted by their efforts to secure an approval for a loan restructure.

On July 2013, the RTC denied respondents’ motion to lift. Respondents’ motion for reconsideration was likewise denied.

Respondents filed a petition for certiorari before the CA. The appellate court lifted the writ of preliminary attachment. It explained that the allegations of Security Bank were insufficient to warrant the provisional remedy of preliminary attachment. It pointed out that fraudulent intent could not be inferred from a debtor’s inability to pay or comply with its obligations. The CA opined that the non-return of the proceeds of the sale and/or the goods subject of the trust receipts did not, by itself, constitute fraud. It held that fraud must be present at the time of contracting the obligation, not thereafter. Security Bank moved for reconsideration but its motion was denied by the CA.

Issue:

Whether or not the CA erred in nullifying the writ of preliminary attachment issued by the trial court

Ruling:

The petition is meritorious. The Court finds that that Security Bank was able to substantiate its factual allegation of fraud, particularly, the violation of the trust receipt agreements, to warrant the issuance of the writ of preliminary attachment.

A writ of preliminary attachment is a provisional remedy issued upon the order of the court where an action is pending. Through the writ, the property or properties of the defendant may be levied upon and held thereafter by the sheriff as security for the satisfaction of whatever judgment might be secured by the attaching creditor against the defendant. The provisional remedy of attachment is available in order that the defendant may not dispose of the property attached, and thus prevent the satisfaction of any judgment that may be secured by the plaintiff from the former.

For a writ of preliminary attachment to issue under Sec. 1(d), Rule 57 of the Rules of Court, the applicant must sufficiently show the factual circumstances of the alleged fraud. It is settled that fraudulent intent cannot be inferred from the debtor’s mere non-payment of the debt or failure to comply with his obligation.

Fraud by its nature is not a thing susceptible of ocular observation or readily demonstrable physically; it must of necessity be proved in many cases by inferences from circumstances shown to have been involved in the transaction in question.

There were violations of the
trust receipt agreements

A trust receipt transaction is one where the entrustee has the obligation to deliver to the entruster the price of the sale, or if the merchandise is not sold, to return the merchandise to the entruster. There are, therefore, two obligations in a trust receipt transaction: the first refers to money received under the obligation involving the duty to turn it over (entregaria) to the owner of the merchandise sold, while the second refers to the merchandise received under the obligation to “return” it (devolvera) to the owner. The obligations under the trust receipts are governed by a special law, Presidential Decree (P.D.) No. 115, and non-compliance have particular legal consequences. The offense punished under P.D. No. 115 is in the nature of malum prohibitum.
The present case only deals with the civil fraud in the non-compliance with the trust receipts to warrant the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment. A fortiori, in a civil case involving a trust receipt, the entrustee’s failure to comply with its obligations under the trust receipt constitute as civil fraud provided that it is alleged, and substantiated with specificity, in the complaint, its attachments and supporting evidence.

Fraud in the performance of
the obligation must be
considered

Previously, in the 1964 Rules of Court, the fraud that justified the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment then was only fraud committed in contracting an obligation (dolo causante). When the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure was issued by the Court, Section 1(d) of Rule 57 conspicuously included the phrase “in the performance thereof”. Hence, the fraud committed in the performance of the obligation (dolo incidente) was included as a ground for the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment.

While the Court finds that Security Bank has substantiated its allegation of fraud against respondents to warrant the issuance of writ or preliminary attachment, this finding should not in any manner affect the merits of the principal case. The writ of preliminary attachment is only a provisional remedy, which is not a cause of action in itself, but is merely adjunct to a main suit.


Republic of the Philippines vs. Mega Pacific eSolutions, Inc., Willy U. Yu, Bonnie S. Yu, Enrique T. Tansipek, Pedro O. Tan, Johnson W. Fong, Bernard I. Fong, and Lauriano A. Barrios, G.R. No. 184666, June 27, 2016 (preliminary attachment)


Republic of the Philippines vs. Mega Pacific eSolutions, Inc., Willy U. Yu, Bonnie S. Yu, Enrique T. Tansipek, Rosita Y. Tansipek, Pedro O. Tan, Johnson W. Fong, Bernard I. Fong, and Lauriano A. Barrios (preliminary attachment)
G.R. No. 184666
June 27, 2016
First Division
Ponente: Sereno, CJ

Gist:

A writ of preliminary attachment may be issued over the properties of incorporators through the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil. To successfully do so, fraud must be sufficiently established by the factual findings of the court and other pronouncements.

Facts:

-   In January 2004, Information Technology Foundation of the Philippines v. Commission on Elections was promulgated where the Supreme Court declared void the automation contract executed by respondent Mega Pacific eSolutions, Inc. (MPEI) and the Commission on Elections (COMELEC) for the supply of automated counting machines (ACMs) for the 2004 national elections.

-   In this Rule 45 Petition assailing the Amended Decision issued by the Court of Appeals, petitioner Republic of the Philippines attempts to cause the attachment of the properties owned by respondent MPEI, as well as by its incorporators and stockholders (individual respondents), in order to secure petitioner’s interest and to secure recovery of the payments it made to respondents for the invalidated automation contract.

Issues:
  1.  Whether petitioner has sufficiently established fraud on the part of respondents to justify the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment in its favor; and
  2. Whether a writ of preliminary attachment may be issued against the properties of individual respondents, considering that they were not parties to the 2004 case
Ruling:

      The Petition is meritorious. A writ of preliminary attachment should issue in favor of petitioner over the properties of respondents on the following grounds: (1) fraud on the part of respondent MPEI was sufficiently established by the factual findings of this Court in its 2004 Decision and subsequent pronouncements; (2) a writ of preliminary attachment may issue over the properties of the individual respondents using the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil; (3) the factual findings of this Court that have become final cannot be modified or altered much less reversed, and are controlling in the instant case; (4) the delivery of 1,991 units of the ACM does not negate fraud on the part of respondents MPEI and Willy; (5) estoppels does not lie against the state when it acts to rectify mistakes, errors or illegal acts of its officials and agents; and (6) the findings of the Ombudsman are not controlling in the instant case.

      For brevity, only the first two findings by the Court shall be discussed in relation to the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment.

1.  Fraud on the part of respondent MPEI was sufficiently established by the factual findings of this Court in the latter’s 2004 Decision and subsequent pronouncements

A writ of preliminary attachment is a provisional remedy issued upon the order of the court where an action is pending. Through the writ, the property of the defendant may be levied upon and held thereafter by the sheriff as security for the satisfaction of whatever judgment might be secured by the attaching creditor against the defendant.

The purpose and function of an attachment or garnishment is twofold. First, it seizes upon property of an alleged debtor in advance of final judgment and holds it subject to appropriation, thereby preventing the loss or dissipation of the property through fraud or other means. Second, it subjects the property of the debtor to the payment of a creditor’s claim, in those cases in which personal service upon the debtor cannot be obtained. This remedy is meant to secure a contingent lien on the defendant’s property until the plaintiff can, by appropriate proceedings, obtain a judgment and have the property applied to its satisfaction, or to make some provision for unsecured debts in cases in which the means of satisfaction thereof are liable to be removed beyond the jurisdiction, or improperly disposed of or concealed, or otherwise placed beyond the reach of creditors.

For a writ of preliminary attachment to issue under Section 1(d), Rule 57 of the Rules of Court, the applicant must sufficiently show the factual circumstances of the alleged fraud.

In Metro, Inc. v. Lara’s Gift and Decors, Inc., the Court explained that “the fraud must relate to the execution of the agreement and must have been the reason which induced the other party into giving consent which he would not have otherwise given.”

2.  Application of the piercing doctrine justifies the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment over the properties of the individual respondents

Petitioner seeks the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment over the personal assets of the individual respondents, notwithstanding the doctrine of separate juridical personality. It invokes the use of the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil.

Veil-piercing in fraud cases requires that the legal fiction of separate juridical personality is used for fraudulent or wrongful ends. As established in the 2004 Decision, four (4) red flags of fraudulent schemes in public procurement were evident in the case, such as: (1) overly narrow specifications; (2) unjustified recommendations and unjustified winning bidders; (3) failure to meet the terms of the contract; and (4) shell or fictitious company.

Because all the individual respondents actively participated in the perpetration of the fraud against petitioner, their personal assets may be subject to a writ of preliminary attachment by piercing the corporate veil.

The main effect of disregarding the corporate fiction is that stockholders will be held personally liable for the acts and contracts of the corporation, whose existence, at least for the purpose of the particular situation involved, is ignored.

It bears stressing that the remaining individual respondents, together with respondent Willy, incorporated MPEI. As incorporators and businessmen about to embark on a new business venture involving a sizeable capital, the remaining individual respondents should have known of Willy’s scheme to perpetrate the fraud against petitioner.

It is clear to the Court that inequity would result if they do not attach personal liability to all the individual respondents. Indeed, to allow the corporate fiction to remain intact would only subvert the ends of justice.

Watercraft Venture Corporation vs. Alfred Raymond Wolfe, G.R. No. 181721, September 9, 2015 (preliminary attachment)


Watercraft Venture Corporation, represented by its Vice-President, Rosario E. RaƱoa v. Alfred Raymond Wolfe (preliminary attachment)
G.R. No. 181721
September 9, 2015
Third Division
Ponente: Peralta, J.

Gist:

Failure to meet one of the requisites for the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment (Sec. 1, ROC 57) warrants the denial of the petition. If all the requisites for the granting of the writ are not present, then the court which issues it acts in excess of its jurisdiction.

Facts:

Sometime in June 1997, petitioner Watercraft Venture Corporation (Watercraft) hired respondent Alfred Raymond Wolfe (Wolfe) as its Shipyard Manager. During his employment, Wolfe stored a sailboat within Watercraft’s boat storage facilities but never paid for the storage fees. On March 2002, Watercraft terminated the employment of Wolfe.

In June 2002, Wolfe pulled out his sailboat from Watercraft’s storage facilities after signing a Boat Pull-Out Clearance representing the unpaid boat storage fees outstanding. Despite repeated demands, he failed to pay his dues.

Three years later, Watercraft filed against Wolfe a Complaint for Collection of Sum of Money with Damages with an Application for the Issuance of a Writ of Preliminary Attachment. The RTC granted Watercraft’s ex-parte application for writ of preliminary attachment pursuant to Section 1 of Rule 57 of the Rules of Court.

Pursuant to the RTC Order, Wolfe’s two vehicles were levied while his BPI accounts were garnished.

On November 2005, Wolfe files a Motion to Discharge the Writ of Attachment, arguing that Watercraft failed to show the existence of fraud and that the mere failure to pay or perform an obligation does not amount to fraud.

The RTC denied Wolfe’s Motion to Discharge Writ of Attachment and Motion for Preliminary Hearing and the latter’s motion for reconsideration.

Meanwhile, the CA granted Wolfe’s petition upon his filing a petition for certiorari. It ruled that the act of issuing the writ of preliminary attachment ex-parte constitutes grave abuse of discretion on the part of the RTC as the said writ failed to allege the requisites prescribed for the issuance. Hence, the issuance of the writ was fatally defective.

Accordingly, although Sec. 1 of Rule 57 allows a party to invoke fraud as a ground for the issuance of a writ of attachment, the Rules require that in all averments of fraud, the circumstances constituting fraud must be states with particularity, pursuant to Rule 8, Section 5. Watercraft’s complaint merely stated, “For failing to pay the use [of] facilities and services – in the form of boat storage fees, the Defendant is clearly guilty of fraud which entitles the Plaintiff to a Writ of Preliminary Attachment upon the property of the Defendant as security for the satisfaction of any judgment herein.”

Issues:
  1.  Whether the ex-parte issuance of the preliminary attachment by the trial court in favor of the petitioner is valid; and
  2. Whether the allegations in the affidavit of merit concerning fraud are sufficient to warrant the issuance of a preliminary writ of attachment by the trial court in favor of the petitioner
Ruling:

The petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court is denied.

A writ of preliminary attachment is defined as a provisional remedy issued upon order of the court where an action is pending to be levied upon the property or properties of the defendant therein, the same to be held thereafter by the sheriff as security for the satisfaction of whatever judgment that might be secured in the said action by the attaching creditor against the defendant. However, it should be resorted to only when necessary and as a last remedy because it exposes the debtor to humiliation and annoyance (Philippine Commercial International Bank v. Alejandro).

Since attachment is harsh, extraordinary, and summary in nature, the rules on the application of a writ of attachment must be strictly construed in favor of the defendant.

For the issuance of an ex-parte issuance of the preliminary attachment to be valid, an affidavit of merit and an applicant’s bond must be filed with the court in which the action is pending. Such bond executed to the adverse party in the amount fixed by the court is subject to the conditions that the applicant will pay: (1) all costs which may be adjudged to the adverse party; and (2) all damages which such party may sustain by reason of the attachment, if the court shall finally adjudge that the applicant was not entitled thereto. As to the requisite affidavit of merit, Section 3, ROC57 of the Rules of Court states that an order of attachment shall be granted only when it appears in the affidavit of the applicant, or of some other person who personally knows the facts: (1) that a sufficient cause of action exists; (2) that the case is one of those mentioned in Section 1 hereof; (3) that there is no other sufficient security for the claim sought to be enforced by the action; and (4) that the amount due to the applicant, or the value of the property the possession of which he is entitled to recover, is as much as the sum for which the order is granted above all legal counterclaims.

The mere filing of an affidavit reciting the facts required by Section 3, Rule 57 is not enough to compel the judge to grant the writ of preliminary attachment. The sufficiency or insufficiency of an affidavit depends upon the amount of credit given it by the judge, and its acceptance of rejection, upon his sound discretion.

After a careful perusal of the foregoing allegations, the Court agrees with the CA that Watercraft failed to state with peculiarity the circumstances constituting fraud, as required by Section 5, Rule 8 of the Rules of Court, and that Wolfe’s mere failure to pay the boat storage fees does not necessarily amount to fraud, absent any showing that such failure was due to insidious machinations and intent on his part to defraud Watercraft of the amount due it.

      In Liberty Insurance Corporation v. CA, the Court explained that to constitute a ground for attachment in Section 1(d), Rule 57 of the Rules of Court, it must be shown that the debtor in contracting the debt or incurring the obligation intended to defraud the creditor. The fraud must relate to the execution of the agreement and must have been the reason which induced the other party into giving consent which he would not have otherwise given”.

      All considered, Watercraft’s Affidavit of Preliminary Attachment does not contain specific allegations of other factual circumstances to show that Wolfe, at the time of contracting the obligation, had a preconceived plan or intention not to pay. It only contained a mere conclusion of law.

      Indeed, if all the requisites for granting such writ are not present, then the court which issues it acts in excess of its jurisdiction.

Labor Law Bar Exam 2019 Syllabus