Showing posts with label counterclaim. Show all posts
Showing posts with label counterclaim. Show all posts

Alex Raul B. Blay v. Cynthia B. Bana - G.R. No. 232189 - March 7, 2018 - Second Division - Ponente: Perlas-Bernabe, J.

A dismissal of an action is different from a mere dismissal of complaint. Since only the complaint and not the action is dismissed, the defendant inspite of said dismissal may still prosecute his counterclaim in the same action.

Facts:


On September 17, 2014, Mr. Blay filed before the Regional Trial Court (RTC) a petition for declaration of nullity of marriage on grounds of psychological incapacity. Three months later, Ms. Bana filed her answer with compulsory counterclaim.


On March 11, 2015, Mr. Blay filed a motion to withdraw his petition. On March 26, 2015, Ms. Bana then invoked Sec. 2, Rule 17 and prayed that her counterclaims be declared as remaining for the court’s independent adjudication. Four days later, she filed her Manifestation. Mr. Blay filed a reply averring that Ms. Bana’s counterclaims are barred from being prosecuted in the same action due to her failure to file a manifestation within fifteen (15) days from the notice of motion to withdraw.


The RTC granted Mr. Blay’s motion to withdraw and declared Ms. Bana’s counterclaim as “remaining for independent adjudication”. The Court of Appeals affirmed the decision of the lower court.


Issue:


Is the respondent’s counterclaim for independent adjudication before the same trial court valid?


Ruling:


No. The RTC should have granted only Mr. Blay’s motion to withdraw and hence, dismissed his petition for declaration of nullity of marriage, without prejudice to the prosecution of Ms. Bana’s counterclaim in a separate action.


When the plaintiff moves for dismissal of complaint to which a counterclaim has been interposed, the dismissal shall be limited to the complaint only. Such dismissal shall be without prejudice to the right of the defendant: (i) to prosecute the counterclaim in a separate action or (ii) to have the counterclaim resolved in the same action.


If the plaintiff elects to prosecute in a separate action, the Court should render the corresponding order granting and reserving the right to prosecute his claim in a separate complaint.


However, if the plaintiff opts to resolve it in the same action wherein the complaint had been dismissed, he must manifest within fifteen (15) days from notice to him of the plaintiff’s motion to dismiss. Failure to manifest within the prescribed time renders the counterclaim to be prosecuted only in a separate action.


The passing of the 15-day period triggers the finality of the court’s dismissal of the complaint and bars the conduct of further proceedings, i.e. the prosecution of respondent’s counterclaim in the same action.


Yolanda Villanueva-Ong v. Juan Ponce Enrile - G.R. No. 212904 - November 22, 2017

Facts:

On October 16, 2012, an article entitled “Like father like son?” was published in the Opinion Section of The Philippine Star. This was authored by petitioner which accused respondent as a liar, fraud, criminal, and car smuggler. Respondent filed a case for libel against petitioner. The latter filed a counterclaim citing her freedom of expression as well as being singled out for harassment as the publisher, editor, and newspaper were not impleaded in the case.

Respondent filed a Motion to Dismiss with the RTC which argued that petitioner’s counterclaims were actually permissive in nature and that her failure to comply with requirements of an initiatory pleading specifically the payment of docket fees and certification against forum shopping will lead to the dismissal of her counterclaims. Petitioner opposed saying that her counterclaims were compulsory in nature.

The Regional Trial Court gave petitioner 15 days from receipt of its order to pay the appropriate docket fees or such counterclaims will be dismissed. The Court of Appeals affirmed the decision of the RTC which dismissed the motion for reconsideration of the petitioner.

Issue:

Whether or not petitioner’s counterclaims are compulsory or permissive in nature

Ruling:

The petition was granted. The Court found the counterclaims as compulsory, that they should be resolved along with the civil complaint filed by respondent without the necessity of complying with the requirements for initiatory pleadings.

A compulsory counterclaim is any claim of money or any relief, which a defending party may have against an opposing party, which at the time of suit arises out of, or is necessarily connected with, the same transaction or occurrence that is the subject matter of the plaintiff’s complaint. Any other counterclaim which is not compulsory is permissive.

In addition, a counterclaim is compulsory if it has a positive answer to all of the following questions:
1. Are the issues of fact and law raised by the claims and counterclaims largely the same?
2. Would res judicata bar a subsequent suit on defendant’s claim, absent the compulsory counterclaim rule?
3. Will substantially the same evidence support or refute plaintiff’s claim as well as defendant’s counterclaim?
4. Is there any logical relation between the claim and counterclaim?

The determination of the nature of the counterclaim is relevant for purposes of compliance to the requirements of initiatory pleadings. For the court to acquire jurisdiction, permissive counterclaims require payment of docket fees while compulsory counterclaims do not.

The complaint filed by respondent for damages arose from alleged malicious publications written by petitioner for the latter’s malice or libelous statements. Meanwhile, petitioner’s counterclaim presupposes bad faith or malice on the part of respondent in instituting complaint for damages.

According to jurisprudence, the theory of malicious prosecution is associated with unfounded criminal actions and baseless civil suits intended to vex and humiliate defendant despite absence of a case of action or probable cause.

Labor Law Bar Exam 2019 Syllabus