Showing posts with label appeal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label appeal. Show all posts

Republic vs. Sps. Benigno, G.R. No. 205492, March 11, 2015 (Sec. 1e, Rule 50)


Republic of the Philippines vs. Spouses Dante and Lolita Benigno
G.R. No. 205492
March 11, 2015
Second Division
Ponente: Del Castillo, J.
keyword: ornery case

Gist:

As a rule, the State is never estopped from questioning the irregular or erroneous acts of its officials. Hence, Sec. 1(e), Rule 50 which provides that a ground for the dismissal of an appeal is failure of the appellant to serve and file the required number of copies of his brief or memorandum within the time provided by the Rules, has no application in the instant case.

Facts:

On November 1995, spouses Dante and Lolita Benigno filed with the RTC of Calamba, Laguna an application for registration of title under Presidential Decree No. 1529 to a lot situated in Los Banos, Laguna.

After trial, the Calamba RTC issued a Decision dated December 9, 2005 granting the spouses’ application for registration.

Petitioner filed its notice of appeal on January 10, 2006. In an April 10, 2006 Order, the trial court approved the notice of appeal and directed that the entire records of the case be forwarded to the CA.

On March 2010, respondents filed a Motion to Dismiss the Appeal and Issue a Final Decree of Registration, claiming among others that petitioner has abandoned its appeal. In a July 2010 Order, the Calamba RTC denied respondent’s motions, stating that it was respondents’ failure to submit certain required documents – the Affidavit of Publication and Certificate of Posting – which caused the non-transmittal of the records of the case to the CA.


Issue:

The CA erred when it ordered the dismissal of the appeal although the delay in the filing of the appellant’s brief was caused by the trial court and the respondents


Ruling:

In Beatingo v. Gasis, the power conferred upon the CA to dismiss an appeal for failure to file an appellant’s brief is discretionary. The Court agrees with the appellate court’s application of Section 1(e), Rule 50 of the Rules. Petitioner took its liberties in the prosecution of its appeal, filing at least three motions for extension of time before finally turning in its appellant’s brief, and taking the demeanor consistent with expecting that each motion for extension of time would be granted.

As a matter of doctrine, illegal acts of government agents do not bind the State, and the Government is never stopped from questioning the acts of its officials, more so if they are erroneous, let alone irregular. This principle applies in land registration cases.

Under the Regalian doctrine, all lands of the public domain belong to the State, and the State is the source of any asserted right to ownership in land and charged with the conservation of such patrimony.

Respondents did not present any documentary evidence in the land registration case to prove that the land applied for is alienable and disposable public land. They even sought the application of the exceptional ruling in Republic v. Vega to obtain exemption from the requirement on the submission of documentary proof showing that the property applied for constitutes alienable and disposable public land.

Consequently, the December 9, 2005 Decision of the Calamba RTC is void. The trial court had no basis in fact and in law to grant respondents’ application for registration as there was no proof of alienability adduced.

A void judgment is no judgment at all. It cannot be the source of any right nor of any obligation.

In this case, respondents cannot invoke Republic v. Vega to claim substantial compliance with the requirement of proof of availability as there is complete absence of documentary evidence showing that the land applied for forms part of the alienable and disposable portion of the public domain.

Mayuga vs. Metrobank, G.R. No. 211499, June 22, 2015 (Section 8, Rule 51)

Catherine Hiponia-Mayuga vs. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co., and its Branch Head, Thelma T. Mauricio, and Belle U. Avelino
G.R. No. 211499
June 22, 2015
Second Division
Ponente: Mendoza, J.

Gist:

As a rule, the CA cannot consider errors on appeal unless stated in the assignment of errors in the appellant’s brief. An exception is, even if a question is not raised in the assignment of errors, the same may still be adjudicated by the appellate court if the unraised issue or question is closely related or dependent to an assigned error.

Facts:

Petitioner Catherine Hiponia-Mayuga was married to the late Fernando J. Mayuga. They owned the subject parcel of land covered by TCT No. 116396 located in Paranaque City. In the course of Fernando’s business dealings, he met Belle Avelino who proposed to him to secure a loan so they could proceed with their business.

On March 1996, Fernando, with Catherine’s consent, obtained a loan from Metrobank in the amount of P 2.2M and, as security thereof, he executed a REM over the subject property.

On July 1996, the loan from Metrobank was increased to P 3.2M with Fernando executing an amendment to the REM. Catherine claimed that the proceeds of the loan went directly to Belle. She admitted, however, that on two occasions Belle gave Fernando the amount of P 100,000.00.

On November 1996, Fernando passed away. Catherine then inquired from Metrobank if the subject property could be released from the mortgage because it was covered by a mortgage redemption insurance (MRI) that paid off the obligation upon the mortgagor’s death. Metrobank, however, replied that Belle was the principal borrower.

On August 1998, Catherine instituted a complaint for the cancellation of the REM and the release of TCT No. 116396 with damages against Belle, Metrobank and Thelma Mauricio, the branch head of Metrobank who allowed the loan.

Meanwhile, Metrobank foreclosed the mortgaged property as Belle failed to pay the loan. As Metrobank was the highest bidder in the foreclosure sale, a Certificate of Sale was issued in its favor.

The RTC ruled that the mortgage contract was valid. It dismissed the complaint against Metrobank and Thelma because it was not proven that the execution of the mortgage was attended with collusion. It also ordered Belle to pay damages to Catherine. In addition, the RTC denied Catherine’s motion for partial reconsideration. On the other hand, Belle did not seasonably file an appeal.

On appeal, the CA deleted the award of damages against Belle. It explained that Fernando was an accommodation mortgagor of Belle’s loan.

Issues:

1. The CA erred in modifying the decision of the trial court by deleting the latter’s award of damages in favor of petitioner against defendant considering that said defendant did not even interpose an appeal in the first place;

2. The CA erred in upholding the trial court’s ruling that there was no connivance between defendant and respondent in the execution of the REM; and

3. The CA erred in upholding the trial court’s ruling that respondent committed no negligence despite failing to secure a mortgage redemption insurance in the person of Mayuga.

Ruling:

1. Belle did not appeal the RTC decision.

The failure of a party to perfect the appeal within the time prescribed by the Rules of Court unavoidably renders the judgment final as to preclude the appellate court from acquiring the jurisdiction to review and alter the judgment. The judgment becomes immutable and unalterable and may no longer be modified in any respect, even if the modification is meant to correct erroneous conclusions of fact and law. An appellee who has not himself appealed cannot obtain from the appellate court any affirmative relief other than those granted in the decision of the lower court.

As far as Belle is concerned, she did not appeal the decision of the RTC. Hence, the RTC decision is final and executor. The award of damages against her, in favor of Catherine, must be upheld.

2. The issues raised by Catherine are not closely related to the damages against Belle

When an appeal is taken, an appellate court acquires jurisdiction to review the case. Section 8, Rule 51 provides:

Sec. 8. Questions that may be decided. No error which does not affect the jurisdiction over the subject matter or the validity of the judgment appealed from or the proceedings therein will be considered, unless stated in the assignment of errors, or closely related to or dependent on an assigned error and properly argued in the brief, save as the court may pass upon plain errors and clerical errors.

As a rule, the CA cannot consider errors on appeal unless stated in the assignment of errors in the appellant’s brief. An exception is, even if a question is not raised in the assignment of errors, the same may still be adjudicated by the appellate court if the unraised issue or question is closely related or dependent to an assigned error.

The two issues raised by Catherine in her appellant’s brief are as follows: (1) that the RTC erred in holding that there was no connivance between Belle and Thelma in the execution of the REM; and (2) that the RTC erred in holding that Metrobank was not negligent. Notably, the issue of Belle’s liability on the payment of the loan was not raised.

An appellant is required by the rules to raise as errors those issues which are sought to be passed upon by the appellate court, otherwise, the CA cannot consider other issues which the appellant failed to raise.

Reliance on Section 8, Rule 51 is misplaced. The exception provided under Section 8, Rule 51, where unraised issues may be adjudicated upon if the same are closely related to an assigned error, cannot be applied in the present case. The first issue of the alleged fraudulent acts of Belle and Thelma is separate and distinct from Belle’s failure to pay the loan. The second issue regarding the negligence of Metrobank is likewise not related to the issue of Belle’s failure to pay the loan. The liability of Metrobank is capable of being addressed separately and rests solely on its failure to secure the MRI in favor of Fernando.

In sum, the issues assigned on appeal do not require the re-examination of the RTC ruling with respect to the award of damages against Belle. These issues cannot be considered as closely related with, or dependent on each other.

3. The exceptions under Section 8, Rule 51 are only for the benefit of the appellant

As previously discussed, the CA can decided issues not assigned as errors but were closely related to or dependent on an assigned error and properly argued by appellants. In PNB vs. Rabat, the Court held that in Section 8, Rule 51, it may at once be noticed that the exceptions are for the benefit of the appellant and not for the appellee.

In the present case, the CA erroneously applied the exception to the benefit of the appellee, Belle, and to the prejudice of the appellant Catherine.

Labor Law Bar Exam 2019 Syllabus