Showing posts with label child witness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label child witness. Show all posts

People of the Philippines v. Francis Ursua y Bernal - G.R. No. 218575 - October 4, 2017

Facts:

AAA, a fourteen-year old minor, lived in a small house with her father Ursua and elder brother, BBB. As the house had no divisions, the three would share the common bed space and sleep side by side.

On 12:00 midnight on January 17, 2006, Ursua undressed AAA, touched her vagina, held her breast, removed his underpants, moved on top of her, pulled his penis, and inserted it into her vagina.

Early dawn the next day, accused repeated the same acts on AAA. Later in the evening of the same day, Ursua once more held AAA’s breasts and vagina and placed himself on top of her.

The genital examination of AAA conducted by the medico-legal officer of the Philippine National Police Crime Laboratory confirmed that there is a clear evidence of remote history of blunt force or penetrating trauma to AAA’s hymen.

The Regional Trial Court found Ursua guilty beyond reasonable doubt for three (3) counts of qualified rape and there being aggravating circumstances, sentenced him to suffer the penalty of three (3) counts of reclusion perpetua. Accused was ordered to pay AAA the amount of PHP 150,000 as civil indemnity, PHP 75,000  as moral damages, and PHP 60,000 as exemplary damages.

The trial court found AAA as a witness and her testimony credible. She positively identified her father as the one who raped her and testified consistently and convincingly on the material facts, including the dates and time that transpired in the alleged incidents.

Meanwhile, the Court of Appeals ruled that Ursua’s denial cannot overcome the positive testimony of AAA. However, in view of failure of the prosecution to prove the fact of penile penetration with regard to the alleged rape that occurred in the evening of January 18, 2006, the appellate court downgraded the offense to acts of lasciviousness. Damages awarded were also modified by said court.

Issue:

Whether the appellate court erred in the penalty imposed and damages awarded to the accused

Ruling:

The Court affirmed the appellate court’s decision but modified it as to the penalty imposed and the damages awarded in the first two criminal cases with respect to two (2) counts of qualified rape by sexual intercourse and to the third criminal case as sexual abuse instead of acts of lasciviousness.

Ursua was made to suffer the penalty of two (2) counts of reclusion perpetua without eligibility for parole and was ordered to pay AAA the amount of PHP 100,000 as civil indemnity, PHP 100,000 as moral damages, and PHP 100,000 as exemplary damages for each count for two (2) counts of qualified rape in the first two criminal cases. He was also made to suffer the penalty of reclusion perpetua with a fine of PHP 15,000, and to pay AAA the amount of PHP 75,000 as civil indemnity, PHP 75,000 as moral damages, and PHP 75,000 for exemplary damages for one (1) count of sexual abuse in the third criminal case.

Republic Act No. 9346, in connection with A.M. No. 15-08-02-SC, states that when circumstances are present warranting the imposition of death penalty, but this penalty is not imposed because of the said Republic Act, the qualification “without eligibility for parole” shall be used to qualify reclusion perpetua in order to emphasize that the accused should have been sentenced to suffer the death penalty had it not been for R.A. No. 9346.

As for the amount of damages awarded, People v. Jugueta provided that in cases of qualified rape where the imposable penalty is death but the same is reduced to reclusion perpetua because of R.A. No. 9346, amounts of civil indemnity, moral damages, and exemplary damages shall be PHP 100,000 each.

People of the Philippines v. Golem Sota and Amidal Gadjadli - G.R. No. 203121 - November 29, 2017

Facts:

On the evening of November 19, 1999, five men went to the residence of the victim, Artemio Eba, and demanded food. The latter was willing to comply on the condition that he would hand the food through an opening in the wall. The group proceeded to light a torch made up of coconut leaves and started to burn the house of Artemio but failed at their first attempt as the latter was able to put out the fire.

The group then demanded Artemio to open the door but the latter refused and insisted that he would hand them the food through the opening in the wall. With this, the group fired at the house, with Gadjali firing the first shot at Artemio. Jocelyn, daughter of the victim, witnessed the events transpire and proceeded to her brother Eusebio’s house. She told her brother about what happened to their father but he did nothing out of fear. Meanwhile, their brother Abelardo did not try to rescue their father when he saw that his father’s house was burning upon the request of his wife not to leave.

The following day, Jocelyn and her siblings found Artemio’s body with stab and gunshot wounds. She then went to the police station at the Municipality of Labason and executed an affidavit.

Issue:

Whether the court a quo failed to prove the guilt of the accused-appellants beyond reasonable doubt

Ruling:

The appeal was denied.

The findings of the trial and appellate courts as to the credibility of Jocelyn were final and conclusive. Credible witness and credible testimony are the two essential elements for determining the weight of a particular testimony.

Jocelyn had no motive in naming Sota and Gadjadli as the perpetrators of the crime.

The defences of alibi and denial proffered by Gota and Gadjadli were intrinsically weak. In deciphering a testimony, the technique is not to consider only its isolated parts nor anchor a conclusion on the basis of said part. For the defense of alibi to prosper, the accused must prove that her was so far away that it was not possible for him to have been physicall present at the place of the crime or at its immediate vicinity at the time of its commission. Generally, the motive of the accused in a criminal case is immaterial and does not have to be proven (People v. De Guzman)

Labor Law Bar Exam 2019 Syllabus